A Few Words About *That*
We haven't really written about the Mitch Mustain situation since starting this blog, mainly because that's last year's news and we're all about being positive and looking forward (editor's note: well, some of the time). But, after the underwhelming aerial attack against Troy we figured it was time to weigh in.
We're not sure if our expat status helps us or hurts us here, but from where we sit, this seems like one of those fun cases where there's plenty of blame to go around. Anyone who says otherwise is probably oversimplifying things. More to the point, this seems like a situation where both parties actually wound up worse off than they were before.
From the Arkansas side, yeah, Mitch wasn't particularly impressive at QB when he played last year, but we need all the arms we can get at this point. And from Mitch's side...well, if he gets a lot of playing time at USC we'll be surprised. This is a guy who was afraid to compete against Casey Dick for the Hogs' starting QB job so he transfers to USC? Those guys sign high school all-Americans like Houston Nutt sends text messages. Maybe he's like a lot of college students and just wanted to live further away from his mom.
0 recs |
7 comments
Comments
Do you really believe in your heart Mitch was afraid to compete with Dick? When you have Gomer Pyle as your head coach and he wants to play cousin Gober in front of you. Well what can you say. The emails where on the wall so to speak. Mitch’s quote that Gomer was an idiot sealed his fate.
by Reader Ken on Sep 4, 2007 3:50 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Who knows what Mitch was thinking? I do know that if he is as good as he says/thinks he is then he would have wound up as the Razorbacks’ starting QB at some point. There’s no way around it.
I think a bigger issue is – whatever Houston Nutt’s good or bad qualities are – you had an 18 year old kid (and his mom) who had essentially done nothing trying to run the show over a guy who, for better or worse, has a proven track record of pretty decent success over a long period of time at the major college level. That was very troubling to me, especially when you consider that proven stars like McFadden, Jones, Hillis, Monk, etc weren’t putting their needs ahead of the team like that.
-John
by Razorback Expats on Sep 4, 2007 5:48 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Mitch shouldn’t have come here in the first place. He didn’t like the coach. Mitch wanted to go to Notre Dame, that didn’t work out for him.
Houston Nutt has NEVER developed a QB so what good would it do for Mustain to stay here? We are NEVER going to have a “great” QB here. We do have some pretty “great” players at other positions, thankfully.
He’s at Southern Cal. They are pretty good. I’m sure he’s having a great time. He’s 19 years old, living in Los Angeles…I bet he’s over it.
How about everybody else get over it, as well?
by CharlieHog on Sep 5, 2007 7:45 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Mitch Mustain was 6-0 , He was pulled out so that a more “experienced” quarterback could start over him. We put a quarterback (Casey Dick) in who had played in a total of 2 games previously.
How does 2 games trump 6 wins in experience?
I think it is clear Mitch was not going to get the playing time even with a better win record.
by Hog FAN on Sep 5, 2007 10:06 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
I don’t think that calling Mitch’s performance unimpressive is quite accurate. If you lined up all of last years quarterback and were asked which one was more “impressive” then the other you’d have give it to Mitch. Sure Casey Dick did have to decent games last year. But Mitch performed quite as badly as Dick did in those last few. But Casey’s our guy now, and its definitely too early make any kind of judgement.
by pubb13 on Sep 5, 2007 3:50 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs

by 












